Skip to Main Content

HU_clock

Freshman Orientation- Library Resources: Scholarly vs. Popular Articles

Video tutorial and quiz regarding library resources.

Peer Reviewed Articles

When you're searching in one of our online databases, it's easy to limit your search to peer-reviewed journals. For example, in Academic Search Complete, there's an option on the main search page under "Limit your results" to limit the search to scholarly (peer reviewed) journals:

 

Peer Review check-box

 

You can also limit your results after you've done a search by clicking the Scholarly (Peer Reviewed) Journals box in the left margin next to the results:

 

Peer Review check-box

Keep in mind that not everything appearing in a peer-reviewed journal is a peer-reviewed article; there are also book reviews, editorials, etc.

Scholarly vs. Popular

 

Scholarly Journals (or peer reviewed)

Popular Magazines

Examples

  • Sociological Review
  • Economic Botany
  • Journal of Asian Studies
  • New England Journal of Medicine

  • PC World
  • Newsweek
  • Psychology Today
  • National Geographic

Content and Format

  • Lengthy, signed articles; usually contain an abstract summarizing the main points
  • Reports of original research
  • In-depth analysis of topics
  • Statistical information
  • Substantial book reviews
  • Refereed/peer reviewed to ensure quality standards of scholarship

  • Short articles, sometimes signed
  • Current events and news
  • Brief, factual information
  • Interviews
  • Some brief book reviews

Language and Audience

  • College-level vocabulary
  • Specialized language of the discipline
  • Written for other academics and experts

  • Non-technical vocabulary
  • Written for general readers

Authors

  • Researchers, academics, scholars
  • Look for credentials, e.g., Ph.D. or affiliation with a university

  • Journalists

Sources

  • Footnotes and bibliographies
  • Extensive documentation

  • Few footnotes
  • Frequently no bibliography

Publishers

  • Professional organizations, universities, research institutes, and scholarly presses

  • Commercial/trade publisher

Graphics

  • Graphs, charts, and tables
  • Ads are very rare

  • Many graphics and photos
  • Abundant advertising; full-page color ads

William R. and Norma B. Harvey Library
757.727.5372

©2016 Hampton University
Hampton, VA 23668 : 757.727.5000